(established at the 2001 Awards Ceremony)
- No award given (2019 – 2020)
- No award given (2016 – 2018)
- Lucy Babbitt/The Winslow Boy (2015)
- No award given (2014)
- Lucy Babbitt/Distracted (2013)
- Alex Carrasco/The Good Doctor (2012)
- Gary Blomberg/Irena’s Vow (2011)
- Joe Mallon/The Right Kind of People (2010)
- Ann Kinner/Moonlight & Magnolias (2009)
- Elizabeth Reynolds/Doubt (2008)
- Steve Kallaugher/The Constant Wife (2007)
- Davina Porter/Rutherford & Son (2006)
- Greg Ellis/Rumors (2005)
- Danielle Sultini/QED (2004)
- Richard Mancini/Inherit the Wind (2003)
- Andre Keuck/The Countess (2002)
- Frank Smith/The Rainmaker (2001)